After Malaysia’s political shift, journalists push for legislative change.

This is what the industry wants.

By Susan Tam
Splice Malaysia
Mahathir Mohamad during the press conference before he was sworn in as Malaysia 7th Prime Minister on May 10, 2018. (Photo: Shutterstock)
Mahathir Mohamad during the press conference before he was sworn in as Malaysia 7th Prime Minister on May 10, 2018. (Photo: Shutterstock)

Now that the dust has settled following Malaysia’s unprecedented election result in May, which saw the Barisan Nasional coalition ousted for the first time in the country’s history, journalists want the new Pakatan Harapan government to realize promises made during the heat of the campaign.

We spoke to Malaysian journalists about just what changes they would like to see to government rules, regulations and policies that have long impacted their work.

Printing presses and official secrets

Leading the calls to repeal the Printing Presses and Publication Act 1984 is Malaysia’s Institute of Journalists. The effort to scrap this act is described as a battle by most, if not all journalists in the country, say IOJ board member Priya Kulasegaran.

A former print reporter for The Star, she says the legislation — which regulates the licensing and operations of Malaysian media outlets — has instilled a culture of self-censorship in most newsrooms, from newsgathering to copy editing.

“Every journalist has been fighting for it to go since the day it was enacted,” she says. “It just needs to go.”

Senior newsman Parkaran Krishnan Kutty, who spent 20 years with The Star and is now a producer for Al Jazeera English, remembers when in October 1987 the Barisan Nasional government, led by first-time Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad, launched a crackdown that saw the arrest of activists and politicians and the closure of several newspapers.

Another hindrance to investigative reporting is the Official Secrets Act 1972, which has been used in the past to prosecute journalists and bloggers, with these journalists saying it must be reviewed or repealed.

And Parkaran says whistleblowers should be given greater protection by amending the Whistleblowers Protection Act 2010.

“For example, allow whistleblowers to report cases to the media or other public agencies, instead of only to enforcement agencies. Also remove limits on the types of information disclosure permitted and protected,” he says.

Revamping licensing procedures

Meanwhile, Edge Media Group publisher Ho Kay Tat says current licensing, which is at the discretion of the Home Affairs Minister, restricts the freedom to publish.

The licensing requirement should be replaced by a requirement that anyone who wants to publish has to register their company and their publishing titles with the ministry,” he says.

Market forces should be the determinant of the success or demise of publishing titles, he argues, not governments.

“There are enough laws, [for] example defamation law, to ensure that publishers are accountable for any wrong reports they publish,” he adds.

Quick fix for fake news

Just one month before the polls, the then-government drafted the Anti-Fake News Act 2018, which was enacted in record time.

Priya from the IOJ recalls attending one of the public consultation sessions held the week before the bill was passed.

“One of our feedback to the then-government was that they had so many laws against the media, so there was no need for another law,” she says.

“Their reply was something to this effect, we are not going to use the law against you, because you’re right, we have many others to use against you.”

Priya feels they rushed the bill to fit their political agenda and muzzle opposing voices with its broad coverage and definitions. As well as imposing tough penalties, the law allows charges to be brought against individuals based outside Malaysia, so long as the alleged ‘fake news’ involves Malaysia or a Malaysian citizen.

And though parliament voted to repeal the bill in August, the Senate recently struck down the measure, meaning that charges can still be brought.

Improving access to information

R.AGE deputy editor Ian Yee says the PPPA and Anti-Fake News Act have created a culture of fear amongst reporters. But now is the time to look toward the future, Yee says.

“After we’ve removed that [legislation], we have to make sure we fill that vacuum with something positive, a culture that encourages brave journalism — like a FOIA,” he adds.

Many journalists in Malaysia want the government to enhance access to public data by enacting the Freedom of Information Act nationwide. Currently only Penang and Selangor enforce this legislation.

And Khaw Chia Hui, a freelance journalist with The News Lens, says there have been a number of hiccups with regards to its implementation.

“Journalists have to check the status of application to information every month and even if you appeal the rejections, there is no guarantee you will receive the documents or a valid explanation,” she says.

Malaysiakini spent two decades fighting for Malaysia’s democracy.

With the opposition in power for the first time since independence, what comes next?


Will their calls be answered?

Journalists are all too familiar with Mahathir’s iron fist.

Mahathir’s reputation as an authoritarian leader was so ingrained that he was named not once, but twice, as one of the 10 Worst Enemies of the Press by the Committee to Protect Journalists.

Now, he is the very person tasked with overhauling a repressive system.

“As pledged in its manifesto, [the government] must repeal the PPPA which is hanging like a sword of Damocles hanging over the media’s heads,” Parkaran says.

Parkaran expresses caution about political promises, but hopes that Mahathir may allow easing of media restrictions now he is a member of a different political coalition, with press freedom advocates in decision-making positions.

“The kind of open reports and discussions we have in the media today is testimony to that hope,” he says.

Susan Tam is a freelance journalist based in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. She has reported on global affairs for Al Jazeera English TV, as well as regional issues for the Singapore Press Holdings and The Star. Her freelance assignments have been for CNN International and Yahoo, and research for the UN offices in Malaysia. Susan specializes in social issues, policy developments and the retail sector. Follow Susan Tam on Twitter.

more about us

Our mission is to drive radical change by supporting bold, forward-looking media startups in Asia. In order to do this, we report on, teach, transform, and fund newsrooms in Asia.

Our newsletters are read by some of the smartest people in global media.

We’re Alan Soon and Rishad Patel, and there’s more about us here.

The Splice Beta Fund is a prototyping grant that helps news and media entrepreneurs in Asia to quickly ideate, launch, test, and iterate products and services for audiences and customers. See our six grantees here!

Splice Lights On is our way of supporting the media community. We are working with Facebook to distribute $5,000 micro-grants in support of small- to mid-sized news orgs and their freelancers in Asia financially affected by Covid-19. See the grantees here.

Splice Low-Res is our virtual community check-in for media startups. Register, watch, sponsor, or stay in the loop here.

Splice is available for speaking engagements, to run workshops, product sponsorships, research, design audits, and consulting. Email us.

We also have a Telegram group. Come say hi.

Subscribe to the Splice YouTube channel.

Thanks for subscribing!